
The publisher's sales pitch for Laura Kasischke's The Raising runs thus: "Imagine if Donna Tartt and Audrey Niffenegger wrote an episode of Twin Peaks..."
Well, obviously this was a red rag to a bull, as far as I was concerned, and I simply had to get hold of an advance copy to prove to myself that it couldn't possibly be as good as that fanboy-wishlist-boxticking tagline would imply. After all, aren't Laura, Donna and Audrey all characters from Twin Peaks? Spooky...
The book that arrived looked, for a worrying moment, to be a young-adult supernatural romance novel in the Stephanie Meyer mould. But fear not.
So, is it particularly reminiscent of Twin Peaks? No, of course not. The magic of that show was all in the soundtrack, the lingering direction and occasional moment of raw horror these two devices could combine to produce. You can't do that in prose (well, I can't, leastways) and all we're left with in the similarities column is that both the book and the TV show begin with the discovery of the dead body of a beautiful, wholesome all-American girl who is revealed, as events follow, to be at once far more and less than she first appears. One could also argue that the Girl on Crutches is not a million miles removed from the character of the Log Lady. But there's nothing in the characterisation within this novel to justify any comparisons with David Lynch and Mark Frost's masterpiece. no-one is as odd, quirky, crazy or stylised as the characters in Peaks.
Are there elements of Donna Tartt? The obvious similarity with The Secret History (it's a campus novel) aside, then still yes. The writing is crisp, occasionally very clever and sometimes funny enough to elicit a proper laugh. The main similarity with Tartt's work is actually with her second novel, The Little Friend, however, in that as you finish the last page, your initial reaction is a frustrated cry of "....AND?"
And is it reminiscent of the writing of Audrey Niffenegger? Again, yes, more or less. The artistic yet craftsmanlike structuring of this novel is its towering accomplishment, as with The Time Traveler's Wife. Two stories unfold in the book simultaneously: the story of what happened after "the accident" and the story of what led up to it. It's a delicate juggling act which Kasischke pulls off expertly. Her writing contains much that is familiar without quite being a cliche, even when writing about over-earnest college kids and their love-lives. The sex was never clumsy or forced, (which is odd since it often involves teenagers...) The atmosphere and tension was ramped up as if by a master of the suspense genre.
I know nothing about Kasischke other than she's a Creative Writing professor, which could make her an American equivalent of Scarlet Thomas, although as a novelist Kasischke is effortlessly superior to Thomas in both skill, style, structure and pacing. Thomas's books are not as clever as she thinks they are, and often her characters prove vastly irritating, with very poor dialogue. You are in a much safer pair of hands with Kasischke. This is a great book which will hold you enthralled right up to the last page.
I imagine that, if Tartt and Niffenegger had got together to write an episode of Twin Peaks, it wouldn't have been a particularly good episode. I'd rather have this book on the shelf than have had an extra episode of my favourite TV show written by two literary fiction writers trying to out show-boat each other in the middle of someone else's franchise. If I want to watch a great TV show interrupted by a famous genre novelist's take on the format, I'll watch the forthcoming episode of Doctor Who written by Neil Gaiman.
But I digress. Read this, if you like the sound of a campus crime thriller tinged with the possible touch of the supernatural. For it is excellent.




